« A Question Of Balance | Main | Oh Dear Lord... »

January 03, 2007

Lord Give Us Chastity And Continence....

...but not quite yet. The House Democrats take a page from St. Augustine:

THE NEW Democratic House majority has an ambitious plan for its first 100 hours in power, from increasing the minimum wage to strengthening ethics rules to having the federal government negotiate prescription drug prices. Unfortunately, its plans don't include getting those provisions passed in the democratic fashion that the Democrats promised to adhere to once in the majority. When Republicans took over in 1995, they at least went through the motions of putting their "Contract With America" proposals through the normal committee process. Democrats under Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) have decided not to bother with that, nor to let Republicans offer amendments on the floor, nor even to put a GOP alternative up for a vote. This is exactly the kind of high-handed mistreatment that Democrats complained about, justifiably, when they were in the minority.

Democrats offer various rationales for their about-face. They say the streamlined process is necessary because they've pledged to accomplish so much in their first 100 legislative hours. But what makes living up to that self-imposed deadline -- which will stretch on for weeks, in any event -- more important than living up to their promise of procedural fairness? And why, even if that deadline is sacrosanct, couldn't Republicans at least be offered an opportunity to offer alternatives on the floor?

Democrats also argue that their proposals have been fully vetted and debated, but in fact many of them involve complex policy choices and some are new proposals. Democrats howled when Republicans moved unilaterally to change the rules governing the operations of the House ethics committee; why is it different for them to move unilaterally to change ethics rules? Questions such as whether the minimum wage increase should be combined with tax breaks for small businesses and whether the federal government should be the only party negotiating Medicare prescription prices ought to be put up for discussion and a vote. If that causes a fracture in the Democratic caucus, so be it.

Republicans, who were only too happy to strong-arm and ignore Democrats when the GOP was in the majority, are now, of course, moaning about being abused. In a nice bit of political theater, they plan to offer Ms. Pelosi's own "Minority Bill of Rights" from 2004, which would provide for, among other things, "open, full and fair debate consisting of a full amendment process."

Democrats say that they'll adhere to their previous promises once their first flurry of business is finished. We look forward to that. But if they don't reconsider, they will set an unfortunate precedent that fairness will be offered on sufferance, when the majority finds it convenient, and not as a matter of principle. That would not be a good start for the 110th Congress.

Since we're waxing Biblical today, all we can add is this: the road to hell is said to be paved with good intentions.

Weren't they going to reinstate oversight of intelligence too?

*crickets chirping*

Posted by Cassandra at January 3, 2007 08:28 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:


It's been awhile since I've seen that quote from Augustine.

And yes, this is an unwelcome but not unsurprising piece of news.

Posted by: karrde at January 3, 2007 02:12 PM

Frankly, we're due for incontinence and some promiscuity. :)

The 110th Congress should be good for lotsa laughs.

Posted by: Don Brouhaha at January 3, 2007 02:21 PM

Due unto others? Unless they did already unto you?

Posted by: KJ at January 4, 2007 12:14 AM

Chastity?! Heaven forfend!!!

Posted by: camojack at January 4, 2007 10:52 AM

The legislative branch isn't going to be doing much at all for some time. Democrats have a majority, but its a very slim one - so anything that one party proposes, the other has a good chance of blocking. They will struggle to squeeze anything through that.

Posted by: Suricou Raven at January 5, 2007 06:38 AM

Post a comment

Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)